Down coats, ski shells, rain jackets and trench coats, compared on fill, seams, hoods, pockets and the temperatures their owners actually wore them in.
8.1score
A featherweight full-zip sun hoodie with thumb holes, and a windproof softshell vest with four pockets: two layers for opposite seasons, and one sizing warning for both.
8.0score
Four long hooded winter coats with detachable faux fur and one light rain shell, all polyester: warm, cheap and well rated, with zipper and sizing caveats.
8.0score
Four hip-length MOERDENG jackets with fleece or quilted linings: the ski jacket has the deepest buyer record, the other three are cheaper and less proven.
7.8score
A low-priced insulated ski jacket that buyers call very warm and waterproof, with a short, wide cut and more zipper complaints than praise.
7.4score
A loose, drop-shoulder zip bomber in 95% polyester quilted knit; buyers rate it 4.4, but the listing leaves out the size chart and every measurement.
7.2score
Every trench detail, cut off at the top of the jeans; 4.1 stars from 1,338 buyers, and a listing that disagrees with itself on fabric and length.
7.0score
An 80/20 wool-blend, single-breasted grey plaid coat that buyers like on sight and argue about on the shoulders: nine of ten sizing mentions are complaints.
Keep browsingAll 123 reviewsThirteen sections, each review ending in a score and a plain verdict.Open | Product | Brand | Price | Amazon rating | Our verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Soothfeel UPF 50+ Sun Protection Hoodie Jacket | Soothfeel | $26.99 | 4.6 (6,683) | 8.3 · We recommend |
| Soothfeel Women's Lightweight Vest with 4 Pockets | Soothfeel | $36.99 | 4.5 (628) | 7.9 · Recommended with caveats |
| MOERDENG Women's Long Hooded Puffer Jacket | Moerdeng | $39.99 | 4.5 (4,391) | 7.9 · Recommended with caveats |
| MOERDENG Women's Long Faux Fur Puffer Coat | Moerdeng | $69.99 | 4.5 (3,331) | 8.2 · We recommend |
| MOERDENG Women's Hooded Softshell Rain Jacket | Moerdeng | $35.99 | 4.6 (3,200) | 7.9 · Recommended with caveats |
| MOERDENG Women's Long Fleece-Lined Down Coat | Moerdeng | $69.99 | 4.5 (2,186) | 7.6 · Recommended with caveats |
| MOERDENG Women's Fleece-Lined Faux Fur Puffer Coat | Moerdeng | $59.99 | 4.6 (1,672) | 8.3 · We recommend |
| MOERDENG Women's Ski Jacket with Detachable Hood | Moerdeng | $69.99 | 4.7 (736) | 8.4 · We recommend |
| MOERDENG Women's Waterproof Hooded Winter Coat | Moerdeng | $29.99 | 4.5 (628) | 7.5 · Recommended with caveats |
| MOERDENG Women's Insulated Hooded Hiking Jacket | Moerdeng | $19.99 | 4.7 (373) | 7.8 · Recommended with caveats |
| MOERDENG Women's Lightweight Full-Zip Puffer Jacket | Moerdeng | $24.99 | 4.5 (271) | 7.7 · Recommended with caveats |
| MOERDENG Women's Ski Jacket | Moerdeng | $39.98 | 4.5 (37,905) | 7.8 · Recommended with caveats |
| Halife Women's Lightweight Bomber Jacket | Halife | $32.99 | 4.4 (50) | 7.4 · Recommended with caveats |
| Saodimallsu Cropped Double-Breasted Trench Coat | Saodimallsu | $39.99 | 4.1 (1,338) | 7.2 · Recommended with caveats |
| BOJIN Men's Plaid Wool-Blend Trench Coat | BOJIN | $79.99 | 4 (294) | 7.0 · Recommended with caveats |